The Events In This Article Are Based On Actual Occurrences. The Names And, In Some Instances, The Genders Of Individuals Have Been Changed To Protect The Individuals’ Privacy.
He opened his laptop and started playing around, again. I hadn’t quite noticed until I’d gotten the rest of this Year 7 class to get their books open and start completing the questions that were on the whiteboard.
It took a good five minutes for them all to settle down.
They’d just been learning about the human body in the best way I could think of: They took apart a life-sized model of a human female (filled with plastic, life-sized organs) and completely rebuilt it.
It had gotten them quite excited; especially the boys, who thought that the mammary glands inside a female breast were completely hilarious!
The class then had to cut and stick a paper human body together – organs included. But he was taking too long.
Christopher was a happy and talkative kid, but his work-rate was slow. On two occasions that lesson I walked over to his desk to help out and remind him to speed up, as everyone else was ahead of where he was. He should have been able to get that work done quickly. He had no Special Educational Needs and his English proficiency had increased so much in three months that he had graduated from the E.L.D. programme.
The only thing slowing him down was his chattiness.
I should have moved him sooner in the lesson – my mistake. 15 minutes before the end of the class I moved him to the front to sit next to me, where he couldn’t chat with friends and be distracted.
It wasn’t enough time.
I pondered the idea of giving him a detention. Break-time was straight after this lesson, so it would be easy for me to keep him behind for ten minutes to get that work done.
The Concept And Purpose Of Detentions
Before we can fully understand how to use detentions effectively, we must first remind ourselves of what detentions are and, therefore, what their purpose should be.
A detention is a period of time that is purposefully taken away from a student’s extra-curricular or non-curricular time. It may involve a teacher-supervised activity during a morning break, lunch or after school.
Detentions are given to students for a wide-variety of reasons; some of which are more logical than others. Reasons for detentions (starting with the most logical and useful) can include:
- Failure to complete homework or classwork
- Poor attendance
- Persistent lateness/lack of punctuality
- Disruption to class activities through poor behavior
- Receiving a certain, set number of ‘warnings’ or ‘demerits’
Christopher’s Case As An Example To Follow
The most logical and useful way to use detentions is time-for-time: time not spent completing homework or classwork should be compensated by time spent on detention.
In Christopher’s case I decided to give the break-time detention. Here are the reasons for my choice:
- The Science lesson ended at break-time, so it was convenient for me to keep him behind in my class (I didn’t have the problem of, say, giving him a lunchtime detention for the next day and then having to remember that he is coming and maybe chase him up if he doesn’t come along).
- Christopher would be exchanging his breaktime for time spent completing his classwork. He must do this, as he will fall behind if he doesn’t.
- The detention serves as a reinforcement of the teacher’s authority, and a stern reminder that a poor work-ethic just won’t be tolerated. It turns out that after only two such break-time detentions, Christopher pulled up his socks and began working at a reasonable pace during lessons.
General Tips For Detentions That Will Save You Many Problems
Every detention must attempt to address or solve the problem that it was given for.
Consider the following:
- Detentions eat up the teacher’s time as well as the students, so we really should only be giving out detentions when it is absolutely necessary (as in Christopher’s case above)
- For homework that’s not done on time: call the perpetrating student or students to your desk for a quick one-to-one discussion at the end of class, or during a class activity. Express your disappointment, and why meeting deadlines is important. Relate it to the world of work, for example “If I didn’t write your reports on time, what would happen to me? That’s right, I’d be in big trouble”. Allow the students an extra day or so to get the work done. No need for conflict, no need to spend your precious lunch time giving a detention.
- If students still don’t hand in the homework even after extending a deadline, then it is necessary to give a detention. CRUCIALLY, however, the purpose of the detention MUST be to complete that homework. Print the sheet again if necessary, provide the necessary resources and get the student to complete the work. This makes the detention less confrontational and reinforces the reason why it was given in the first place.
- The same goes for classwork: give students the chance to take their books home and complete classwork if it isn’t done on-time in class. Persistent slow work-rates in class, if not caused by reasonable circumstances (such as Special Educational Needs), should be met with detentions that allow the student to catch up. In almost every case you’ll find that the students will cotton-on to the fact that they can’t get away with distraction and laziness in class, and they’ll soon improve. For those that don’t improve even after focused detentions, further action will be needed and may involve parents and senior/middle management.
- For poor behavior, detentions need to be planned and crafted really well. Remember: the detention should attempt to address or solve the problem that it was given for. I remember a couple of years back when two boys got involved in a bit of a scuffle in the science lab. It wasn’t anything major, but one kid said a nasty word to the other and that kid decided to punch his mate in the arm quite hard. As a Science Teacher, this is something I must absolutely nip-in-the-bud because safety in the lab is paramount, and kids just can’t scuffle or fight in there: period. I gave them both a detention for the next day at 1pm. They came, and I spent the time explaining to them why their behavior was unacceptable. They wrote letters of apology to me and each other, and left the detention understanding exactly why I had taken their time away from them. I didn’t have a problem with them again.
- Lessons that end at break times work well for giving detentions if necessary, as you can easily retain the students when the bell rings. If you do assign detentions for the next day or at a later time, then pencil those into your diary – this will serve both as a useful reminder and as a record of who’ve you’ve given detentions to and how often.
Recurring Work
I’m a massive believer in the power of recurring work and journaling, and have written about it in detail here and here.
Learning journals are just great for giving regular recurring feedback and for consolidating and reviewing cumulative knowledge gained throughout an academic year. But did you know that Learning Journals save you many a supervised detention too?
Many schools provide homework timetables for students and teachers to follow. With the very best of intentions, these timetables aim to distribute student and teacher workload evenly and fairly. However, they can prove difficult to follow when units include different intensities of work, and when school events get in the way.
That’s where Learning Journals come in!
Set Learning Journals as homework each week. The basic idea is that students buy their own notebook and fill it with colorful revision notes on a weekly basis (although they can be done online too: through Google Sites, for example). Perhaps your Year 10 class could hand-in their learning journals in every Wednesday, and collect them from you (with feedback written inside, see the articles cited above) every Friday. By setting up a register of collection that the students sign, you can easily see who hasn’t handed in their journal that week.
Then……follow the guidelines given above for dealing with late or un-submitted homework. You’ll find that after a few weeks of initiating Learning Journals you’ll get a near 100% hand-in rate, because the students are really clear about what is expected each week, because it is a recurring homework.
Whole School Considerations
Many schools adopt a popular (but massively problematic) ‘mass-detention’ system of some sort, which works something like this:
- The student receives the requisite number of ‘warnings’ in a particular lesson which lead to a break or lunch time detention being given
- The student is sent to a room with other students from the school who’ve also received detentions
- Teachers supervise the ‘detention room’ on a rotating basis, thereby (in theory), sharing the workload across the staff body
- The students are given generic tasks to do during the detention time, which may include filling in a form, completing homework or in the very worst cases just sitting still and being quiet for twenty minutes or so.
The problem with systems like this is that they are not personal to the students receiving the detentions. They do not follow the ‘golden rule’: that detentions should address or solve the problem that they were given for.
What’s much more effective in the long-term is to trust individual teachers to administer their own detentions. Perhaps provide a quick training session based on good practice (feel free to use this article if you wish), and allow the teachers to then use their judgement to decide when and how detentions should be given.
Conclusion
Student detentions are only effective when they have the ‘personal touch’. When detentions address the original issue by allowing more time to complete homework or classwork, or allow for a one-on-one discussion about behavior, the following magical things happen:
- The detention is given from a standpoint of care and concern, not confrontation and aggression
- Students realize the reason why the detention was given as this reason is reinforced by the activities given during the time of the detention
- Students improve. It’s that simple. Mass detention systems rarely work because they don’t pinpoint the personal reasons behind why the student is under-performing. Detentions with the ‘personal touch’ cause students to realize their errors and most, if not all, will improve in a short space of time.
Thanks Richard James Rogers (Author of The Quick Guide to Classroom Management) / RichardJamesRogers
https://richardjamesrogers.com/2018/05/13/the-effective-use-of-detentions/
Please Extend Your Patronage...
Kindly Like, Comment, Share, Following:-
"Knowledge Center" For Latest Updates ... Facebook.com/KnowledgeCenter3579
"Knowledge Center" For Latest Updates ... https://ZiaullahKhan.blogspot.com
To Support Facebook “Knowledge Center” & Blog “Knowledge Center” Contents, Please Use This Link: - PayPal.me/ZiaullahKhan1
Or Use this Email Address for PayPal (To Support Knowledge Center Channel):-KnowledgeCenter3579@gmail.com
Amazon USA :- https://amzn.to/2GjhTaB
Amazon UK :- https://amzn.to/2ByqMcp
Amazon Italy :- https://amzn.to/2BEV0e3 (Libri)
Amazon Italy :- https://amzn.to/2TGMHoJ (Libri In Altre Lingue)
Amazon Spain :- https://amzn.to/2WUIYWL (Libros)
Amazon Spain :- https://amzn.to/2TJizZQ (Libros En Idiomas Extranjeros)
Amazon France :- https://amzn.to/2TJmuWA (Livres)
Amazon France :- https://amzn.to/2WUJlR9 (Livres Anglais Et Etrangers)
Amazon Canada :- https://amzn.to/2TMkVHK (English)
Amazon Canada :- https://amzn.to/2thpf68 (Livres En Français)
Amazon Germany :- https://amzn.to/2THR7Mh (Bücher)
Amazon Germany :- https://amzn.to/2THR7Mh (Bücher Fremdsprachig)
Amazon Germany :- https://amzn.to/2I5v54H (English)
Amazon Germany :- https://amzn.to/2THohvt (Dutch)
Amazon Germany :- https://amzn.to/2GlQNzM (Netherland)
Amazon Germany :- https://amzn.to/2Gjkz89 (Poland)
Amazon Australia :- https://amzn.to/2Go0c9Y
